All-Americans

Baseball
Cory Briggs (2008), Second Team - ABCA/Rawlings
Bruce Cameron (2008), Second Team - D3Baseball.com
Robby Finnell (2008), Second Team - D3Baseball.com

Men's Basketball
Stephen Kennedy (1993-1994), Third Team - NAIA
Stephen Kennedy (1992-1993), Honorable Mention - NAIA
Ricky Donnerson (1987-1988), Second Team - NAIA
Tony Joyner (1983-1984), Third Team - NAIA 

Men's Track
Percy Williams (1983) - NAIA
Percy Williams (1982) NAIA
Percy Williams (1981) NAIA
Kenneth Little (1980) - NAIA

Women's Basketball
Jennifer Ewing (1997-1998), Honorable Mention - D3Hoops.com
Lori Myers (1996-1997), Second Team - NAIA
Becky Stoltenberg (1996-1997), Honorable Mention - NAIA
Becky Stoltenberg (1995-1996), Second Team - NAIA 
Lori Myers (1995-1996), Honorable Mention - NAIA 
Penni Peppas (1993-1994), First Team - NAIA  
Penni Peppas (1992-1993), Second Team - NAIA
Penni Peppas (1992-1993), Kodak All-American
Penni Peppas (1991-1992), Third Team - NAIA  

Wrestling
Nathan Rankin (2019-2020), Second Team - NWCA

Academic All-Americans
Baseball
Chase Edwards (2020), First Team - Google Cloud Academic All-America
Chase Edwards (2019), Second Team - Google Cloud Academic All-America
Sam Shook (2013), Third Team - Capital One Academic All-America 
Michael Prusator (2012), Third Team - Capital One Academic All-America
Robby Finnell (2008), First Team - ESPN The Magazine Academic All-America

Men's Soccer
Thomas Ross (2018), First Team - Google Cloud Academic All-America
Brian Sarber (2008), Third Team - ESPN The Magazine
Ron Hogsett (2005), Second Team - ESPN The Magazine Academic All-America

Men's Tennis
Todd Turner (2015), First Team - Capital One Academic All-America
Todd Turner (2014), Third Team - Capital One Academic All-America 

Women's Basketball
April Young (2011-2012), Second Team - Capital One Academic All-America

Wrestling
Jerhett Lee (2018-2019) - NWCA All-Academic Team
Devon Jackson (2017-2018) - NWCA All-Academic Team
Nathan Rankin (2017-2018) - NWCA All-Academic Team